Educational Research

Educational Research (ISSN:2141-5161) Vol. 3(3), pp. 222-247, March 2012         
Copyright © 2012 International Research Journals


Full Length Research Paper 

Establishing reliability of graduates’ self-assessment of acquired generic competences: An innovative approach

1Ashfaque Ahmad Shah*, Uzma Shahzadi, 2Jean-Jacques Paul

1Centre for Economics of Education, Department of Education, University of Sargodha, 40100 Sargodha, Pakistan

2IREDU UMR 5225 CNRS/Université de Bourgogne, Pôle AAFE-Esplanade Erasme-BP 26513, F - 21065 Dijon Cedex, France 

*Corresponding Author E-mail:

Received 01 February, 2012; Accepted 15 February, 2012


Since self-assessment is often questioned for its subjectivity, our main concern in this article is to study the reliability of self-assessment of higher education graduates’ competences with a different approach. This is to answer in particular, “to what extent self-assessment of graduates’ competences is reliable”, if reliability does exist therein. We used the data set of Reflex project which was carried out under the 6th framework programme of European Union. We employed ordered probit, OLS regression, parametric and nonparametric analyses of variance with the help of SPSS and Stata.  Making use of some objective information along with the subjective one, we found nothing contradictory to our reliability hypothesis. We employed the parameters of coherence and consistency to our findings in order to draw conclusions. We feel confident to say that graduates’ self-assessment of competences is found to be, in Popperian terms, reliable to a modest extent. The fact that the respondents knew, at the time of survey, that they will not be harmed, could be regarded as a limitation to this study. We have explored only the acquired level of competences in this study. However, we suggest analysing assessment of required competence level of young knowledge workers in the labour market employing the same methodology (to the permissible extent) in order to delineate a comparative description; and this is what provides substance for our subsequent study.


Keywords: Reliability, self-assessment, generic competence, higher education, graduates, ordered probit, nonparametric ANOVA.

[View Full Article - HTML]   [View Full Article - PDF]   [Download Full Article - PDF]